By using this site, you agree to the Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.
Accept

News Junction

Notification Show More
Font ResizerAa
  • Home
  • World News
    World NewsShow More
    Why is Germany such a mess? — RT World News
    Why is Germany such a mess? — RT World News
    May 11, 2025
    Pope Leo explains name: AI, worker rights
    Pope Leo explains name: AI, worker rights
    May 11, 2025
    Ukraine and allies urge Putin to commit to a 30-day ceasefire or face new sanctions – National
    Ukraine and allies urge Putin to commit to a 30-day ceasefire or face new sanctions – National
    May 11, 2025
    Mexican-American singer Johnny Rodriguez, whose 1970s country hits topped charts, dies at 73
    Mexican-American singer Johnny Rodriguez, whose 1970s country hits topped charts, dies at 73
    May 11, 2025
    How this ‘generational shift’ impacts fitness, wellness industries
    How this ‘generational shift’ impacts fitness, wellness industries
    May 10, 2025
  • Business
    BusinessShow More
    Ukraine blows up bridges to consolidate its positions in Russia
    Ukraine blows up bridges to consolidate its positions in Russia
    August 18, 2024
    Commentary: AI phones from Google and Apple will erode trust in everything
    Commentary: AI phones from Google and Apple will erode trust in everything
    August 18, 2024
    The most famous Indian Dishes – Insights Success
    The most famous Indian Dishes – Insights Success
    August 18, 2024
    Life on the road as a female long rides cyclist
    Life on the road as a female long rides cyclist
    August 18, 2024
    UK inflation rises to 2.2%
    UK inflation rises to 2.2%
    August 18, 2024
  • Cryptocurrency
    CryptocurrencyShow More
    Ex-UFC champ Conor McGregor touts Irish Bitcoin reserve in presidential bid
    Ex-UFC champ Conor McGregor touts Irish Bitcoin reserve in presidential bid
    May 11, 2025
    Ethereum, Dogecoin, and Bitcoin Pepe
    Ethereum, Dogecoin, and Bitcoin Pepe
    May 11, 2025
    Taiwan eyes Bitcoin as hedge against inflation and US Treasury exposure
    Taiwan eyes Bitcoin as hedge against inflation and US Treasury exposure
    May 11, 2025
    Cyzens Initiates A New Epoch for Decentralized Media Realm with NFTs
    Cyzens Initiates A New Epoch for Decentralized Media Realm with NFTs
    May 11, 2025
    Virginia Man Gets 30 Years For Supporting ISIS
    Virginia Man Gets 30 Years For Supporting ISIS
    May 10, 2025
  • Technology
    TechnologyShow More
    How to Improve Your Spotify Recommendations
    How to Improve Your Spotify Recommendations
    August 18, 2024
    X says it’s closing operations in Brazil
    X says it’s closing operations in Brazil
    August 18, 2024
    Supermoon set to rise: Top tips for amateur photographers | Science & Tech News
    Supermoon set to rise: Top tips for amateur photographers | Science & Tech News
    August 18, 2024
    Scientists Want to See Videos of Your Cat for a New Study
    Scientists Want to See Videos of Your Cat for a New Study
    August 18, 2024
    OpenAI’s new voice mode let me talk with my phone, not to it
    OpenAI’s new voice mode let me talk with my phone, not to it
    August 18, 2024
  • Entertainment
  • Sports News
  • People
  • Trend
Reading: IR35 public sector reforms: HS2 finalises £6.2m settlement with HMRC over compliance failings
Share
Font ResizerAa

News Junction

  • World News
  • Business
  • Technology
  • Cryptocurrency
  • Trend
  • Entertainment
Search
  • Recent Headlines in Entertainment, World News, and Cryptocurrency – NewsJunction
  • World News
  • Business
  • Cryptocurrency
  • Technology
  • Entertainment
  • Sports News
  • People
  • Trend
Have an existing account? Sign In
Follow US
News Junction > Blog > Technology > IR35 public sector reforms: HS2 finalises £6.2m settlement with HMRC over compliance failings
IR35 public sector reforms: HS2 finalises £6.2m settlement with HMRC over compliance failings
Technology

IR35 public sector reforms: HS2 finalises £6.2m settlement with HMRC over compliance failings

Published August 15, 2024
Share
6 Min Read
SHARE

High Speed Two (HS2), the public body responsible for developing the UK’s high-speed rail network, has confirmed it paid HM Revenue & Customs (HMRC) a final settlement of £6.2m for failing to comply with the IR35 tax avoidance legislation.

The settlement amount is several million pounds lower than HS2 originally budgeted for, as confirmed by the contents of its 2023–24 annual report and accounts, which state the organisation initially set aside £10.2m to cover the cost of its IR35 liabilities.

As previously reported by Computer Weekly in August 2022, HS2’s compliance with the IR35 legislation has been subject to an ongoing review since May 2022, after concerns were raised about how the organisation adapted to the roll-out of the public sector IR35 reforms in April 2017.

“In [the] 2022–23 [financial year], the company made a provision for £10.2m for tax that could have been due to HMRC in relation to the Off-Payroll Working Legislation introduced in April 2017,” the HS2 accounts document stated.

“HMRC [has] now undertaken a compliance review covering the historic assessment of contractors’ employment status resulting in the company making a payment of £6.2m to cover the full value of the identified liability,” it added.

“The HMRC review has now been formally concluded and accordingly, there is no provision included for the year ended 31 March 2024.”

The accounts, which cover the 12 months to 31 March 2024, also show that HS2 engaged a total of 339 off-payroll workers during this period, with 320 (94%) determined to be working on an inside IR35 basis.

Dave Chaplin, CEO and founder of IR35 compliance firm IR35 Shield, said these figures are concerning, and suggest the HS2 could be paying over the odds for the highly-skilled individuals it needs to deliver the project. “The human cost is concerning, with only 5% of contractors deemed to be outside IR35, we’re likely to see top talent blackball the HS2 project, leading to higher cost alternatives,” he said.

This is because inside IR35 contractors may typically request higher day rates to compensate for the fact they will be paying additional employment-related tax on their earnings, compared with individuals working on an outside IR35 basis.

It’s an issue Computer Weekly recently reported on, in the wake of chancellor Rachel Reeves announcing a clampdown on government departmental spend on external consultancies, as part of a push to close the £22bn public spending gap the new government claims to have inherited from the Conservatives.

This is not the only way the public sector IR35 reforms are costing the public sector money, added Chaplin, as the HS2 accounts neatly show.

“[This HS2 bill] is highlighting the circular and counterproductive nature of off-payroll legislation in the public sector,” he said. “HS2, funded by the government, pays £6.2m to HMRC, which goes to the Treasury, only for the Treasury to then fund HS2 with monies including this £6.2m. It’s a bureaucratic circus that serves no real purpose.

“The compliance efforts themselves are a net loss for the Treasury,” added Chaplin. “HMRC caseworkers’ salaries result in only about a third returning as tax revenue. Add to this the increased costs from pushing contractors onto payroll and the use of consultancies, and we’re looking at a significant net loss for the public purse.”

When details of HS2’s IR35 compliance issues first emerged, the organisation’s accounts confirmed it had relied on HMRC’s much-maligned Check Employment Status for Tax (CEST) online tool to assess the employment status of its contractors.

Handle with care

Seb Maley, CEO of contractor insurance provider Qdos, said the situation raises “serious questions” about whether CEST is fit for purpose, but should also highlight the reasons why contractor status determinations are something that need to be handled with care.

“Time and time again, CEST is at the heart of incorrect IR35 assessments,” he said. “This eye-watering tax bill serves as a lesson for other businesses engaging contractors. Given the complexity and the concerns of these rules, it’s crucial that compliance is prioritised.”

There is another concerning element to the story, said Maley, which is the length of time HS2 appears to have been under investigation by HMRC, and how long it has taken the organisation to get clarification on how big its IR35-related tax bill would be.

“Such lengthy delays breed uncertainty, which isn’t good for any organisation – and in many ways, contractors,” he said. “It’s one thing for a public sector organisation to have a £10m tax bill hanging over its head, but it’s another thing altogether for private sector firms.

“The reality is, the longer an IR35 investigation is open, the bigger the impact it can have on whether a business engages contractors. Time spent waiting on HMRC is a huge problem. We see it day in day out here at Qdos, where businesses can’t look too far ahead because of an ongoing – and lengthy – investigation.”

#IR35 #public #sector #reforms #HS2 #finalises #6.2m #settlement #HMRC #compliance #failings

TAGGED:6.2mcompliancefailingsfinalisesHMRCHS2IR35publicreformssectorsettlement
Share This Article
Facebook Twitter Pinterest Whatsapp Whatsapp LinkedIn Email Copy Link Print
Share
What do you think?
Love0
Sad0
Happy0
Sleepy0
Angry0
Dead0
Wink0
Previous Article Pete Davidson checks out of rehab after just two weeks amid fears over his ‘unpredictable’ behavior following Madelyn Cline split Pete Davidson checks out of rehab after just two weeks amid fears over his ‘unpredictable’ behavior following Madelyn Cline split
Next Article Bitcoin ETFs Racing To Overtake Satoshi’s Iconic BTC Stash — Analyst Bitcoin ETFs Racing To Overtake Satoshi’s Iconic BTC Stash — Analyst
- Advertisement -

Latest Post

Why is Germany such a mess? — RT World News
Why is Germany such a mess? — RT World News
World News
Ex-UFC champ Conor McGregor touts Irish Bitcoin reserve in presidential bid
Ex-UFC champ Conor McGregor touts Irish Bitcoin reserve in presidential bid
Cryptocurrency
Pope Leo explains name: AI, worker rights
Pope Leo explains name: AI, worker rights
World News
Ethereum, Dogecoin, and Bitcoin Pepe
Ethereum, Dogecoin, and Bitcoin Pepe
Cryptocurrency
Taiwan eyes Bitcoin as hedge against inflation and US Treasury exposure
Taiwan eyes Bitcoin as hedge against inflation and US Treasury exposure
Cryptocurrency
Ukraine and allies urge Putin to commit to a 30-day ceasefire or face new sanctions – National
Ukraine and allies urge Putin to commit to a 30-day ceasefire or face new sanctions – National
World News
- Advertisement -

You Might Also Like

Gaming Aim Training Tournaments : playdays the gauntlet
Technology

Gaming Aim Training Tournaments : playdays the gauntlet

August 15, 2024
Identity.vc is bringing capital and community to Europe’s LGBTQ+ venture ecosystem
Technology

Identity.vc is bringing capital and community to Europe’s LGBTQ+ venture ecosystem

July 1, 2024
The Acolyte Finale Manny Jacinto Interview: Stranger’s Secrets
Technology

The Acolyte Finale Manny Jacinto Interview: Stranger’s Secrets

July 19, 2024
Simplyblock targets ‘complex’ Ceph with software-defined NVMe
Technology

Simplyblock targets ‘complex’ Ceph with software-defined NVMe

August 21, 2023

About Us

NEWS JUNCTION (NewsJunction.xyz) Your trusted destination for global news. Stay informed with our timely and accurate reporting on diverse topics, including politics, technology, science, entertainment, sports, and more. Count on us for unbiased and reliable updates at your fingertips.

Quick Link

  • About
  • Disclaimer
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Contact

Top Categories

  • World News
  • Business
  • Technology
  • Entertainment
  • Cryptocurrency
  • Sports News
  • Trend
  • People

Subscribe

Subscribe to our newsletter to get our newest articles instantly!

    © 2023 News Junction.
    • Blog
    • Advertise
    • Contact
    Welcome Back!

    Sign in to your account

    Username or Email Address
    Password

    Lost your password?