By using this site, you agree to the Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.
Accept

News Junction

Notification Show More
Font ResizerAa
  • Home
  • World News
    World NewsShow More
    Guide to Pope Leo XIV’s inauguration
    Guide to Pope Leo XIV’s inauguration
    May 17, 2025
    ‘He’s the chosen one’: Meet the 14-year-old British boxer now fighting for Bahrain | World News
    ‘He’s the chosen one’: Meet the 14-year-old British boxer now fighting for Bahrain | World News
    May 17, 2025
    Trump’s Gulf Tour: The Money Deals, the Diplomacy and What Comes Next
    Trump’s Gulf Tour: The Money Deals, the Diplomacy and What Comes Next
    May 17, 2025
    ‘I cannot stand by’: Former ambassador denounces Ukraine shift under Trump | Donald Trump News
    ‘I cannot stand by’: Former ambassador denounces Ukraine shift under Trump | Donald Trump News
    May 17, 2025
    Trump says ex-FBI director called for his ‘assassination’ — RT World News
    Trump says ex-FBI director called for his ‘assassination’ — RT World News
    May 17, 2025
  • Business
    BusinessShow More
    Ukraine blows up bridges to consolidate its positions in Russia
    Ukraine blows up bridges to consolidate its positions in Russia
    August 18, 2024
    Commentary: AI phones from Google and Apple will erode trust in everything
    Commentary: AI phones from Google and Apple will erode trust in everything
    August 18, 2024
    The most famous Indian Dishes – Insights Success
    The most famous Indian Dishes – Insights Success
    August 18, 2024
    Life on the road as a female long rides cyclist
    Life on the road as a female long rides cyclist
    August 18, 2024
    UK inflation rises to 2.2%
    UK inflation rises to 2.2%
    August 18, 2024
  • Cryptocurrency
    CryptocurrencyShow More
    BTC, ETH, XRP, BNB, SOL, DOGE, ADA, SUI, LINK, AVAX
    BTC, ETH, XRP, BNB, SOL, DOGE, ADA, SUI, LINK, AVAX
    May 17, 2025
    Altcoins are on the verge of ‘most powerful rally’ since 2017 — Analyst
    Altcoins are on the verge of ‘most powerful rally’ since 2017 — Analyst
    May 17, 2025
    Tokenization makes investing more accessible — Robinhood exec
    Tokenization makes investing more accessible — Robinhood exec
    May 17, 2025
    World Liberty Financial brushes off oversight concerns from Congress
    World Liberty Financial brushes off oversight concerns from Congress
    May 17, 2025
    Onyxcoin price soars as 24-hour volume explodes 600%
    Onyxcoin price soars as 24-hour volume explodes 600%
    May 17, 2025
  • Technology
    TechnologyShow More
    How to Improve Your Spotify Recommendations
    How to Improve Your Spotify Recommendations
    August 18, 2024
    X says it’s closing operations in Brazil
    X says it’s closing operations in Brazil
    August 18, 2024
    Supermoon set to rise: Top tips for amateur photographers | Science & Tech News
    Supermoon set to rise: Top tips for amateur photographers | Science & Tech News
    August 18, 2024
    Scientists Want to See Videos of Your Cat for a New Study
    Scientists Want to See Videos of Your Cat for a New Study
    August 18, 2024
    OpenAI’s new voice mode let me talk with my phone, not to it
    OpenAI’s new voice mode let me talk with my phone, not to it
    August 18, 2024
  • Entertainment
  • Sports News
  • People
  • Trend
Reading: Tongaat shareholders advised to sell, even for 1c per share
Share
Font ResizerAa

News Junction

  • World News
  • Business
  • Technology
  • Cryptocurrency
  • Trend
  • Entertainment
Search
  • Recent Headlines in Entertainment, World News, and Cryptocurrency – NewsJunction
  • World News
  • Business
  • Cryptocurrency
  • Technology
  • Entertainment
  • Sports News
  • People
  • Trend
Have an existing account? Sign In
Follow US
News Junction > Blog > Business > Tongaat shareholders advised to sell, even for 1c per share
Tongaat shareholders advised to sell, even for 1c per share
Business

Tongaat shareholders advised to sell, even for 1c per share

Published January 22, 2024
Share
10 Min Read
SHARE

Tongaat Hulett’s thousands of shareholders should sell their shares in the financially-distressed suspended JSE-listed sugar producer and property developer – even for 1 cent per share – to limit their losses, says an analyst.

This follows the approval this month at a meeting of affected persons of the Vision Group’s business rescue plan, which will lead to a significant dilution in value for shareholders.

ADVERTISEMENT

CONTINUE READING BELOW

Read:

Tongaat shareholders set to receive nothing for their shares
Approval of Tongaat Hulett rescue plan ‘a great milestone’

The Vision plan includes:

  • The acquisition of the lender group claims and security amounting to about R8 billion and subsequent conversion of about R4.1 billion of these claims into new equity in Tongaat; and

  • Shareholders retaining an interest of 2.7% in Tongaat equity after the debt-to-equity conversion.

An analyst who did not want to be named said Tongaat’s shareholders are “being wiped out” by the Vision plan.

He said the lender group takes an about 50% “hit” on their debt and Vision indicated that shareholders get 2.7%.

However, the analyst said that is purely a mathematical outcome of Vision issuing the five billion maximum number of authorised shares that exist and existing shareholders retaining the 135 million shares that are in the offer, which is exactly 2.7%.

“Vision believes it can just bluntforce their way into issuing all the shares for a swap of debt without any shareholder approval or special resolution, and indicated that the remaining R3.6 billion in debt will remain on the balance sheet,” he said.

“Vision’s notion of shareholder value retention is bull*** because there isn’t going to be anything left for shareholders.”

Read: Tongaat rescue plan: ‘Creditors have the final say’

Tongaat’s business rescue practitioners (BRPs), Metis Strategic Advisors, confirmed on 12 January 2024 that: “The preliminary approval has become final due to the rights of shareholders not being affected and therefore no shareholder vote being required.”

The analyst added that trading creditors get five cents in the rand and “shareholders get absolutely nothing”.

“The 2.7% is an illusion, it’s zero. The reason simply is that they still keep R9 billion of debt on the balance sheet and many moons will be required to pay that up.”

Read:

The analyst said shareholders would be wise to sell their shares for one cent per share.

“At least then they get a tax deduction because of a capital loss, which is at least an 18% return through an offset from their capital gains from Sars [South African Revenue Service],” he said.

Shareholder activist Chris Logan said Tongaat shareholders will still have an interest in the group but it will be “worth next to nothing”.

However, Logan said until Vision and the BRPs report on the ratios and provide more information going forward, it was not possible to work it out what the shares are worth.

“It’s all guesstimates. Even if they told you how much debt they were going to convert into equity and how many shares they have versus the existing shareholder base, it would still be very difficult because you’d still then have to work out what the business is worth going ahead,” he said.

‘Rudland resolution’ remains in place

Charles Liasides, a director of Artemis Investments, which as at 3 November 2023 owned 20.1 million shares in Tongaat Hulett or 14.878% of the group’s issued shares, said shareholders will be “horribly” diluted by the Vision plan.

Liasides said that when trading in Tongaat shares on the JSE was suspended, the 135 million listed shares were trading at about R4 per share, which translates into about R500 million, but Vision wants to convert about R4.1 billion in debt into shares.

He said a resolution was approved by Tongaat shareholders to extend the share capital of the group when Zimbabwe’s billionaire Rudland family were trying to take over the company and the number of shares that can be issued was increased to five billion.

Read: Tongaat Hulett secures shareholder approval for controversial rights offer

“That resolution remains in place so all Vision has to do is to take that accumulated supposed equity they have put into Tongaat, which has been borrowed in various places, and convert it into shares and then shareholders are totally diluted and out of the picture.

“The whole process of increasing Tongaat’s issued shares to that level will result in an automatic massive dilution of existing shareholder value,” he said.

Liasides said shareholders get left with nothing because the business rescue plan is only ever voted on by the creditors.

ADVERTISEMENT

CONTINUE READING BELOW

He admitted there are reasons for this but one of the negatives of it is obviously that “the shareholders have no say and stand to be horribly diluted, which has happened in this instance”.

BRPs ‘had better options’

Liasides said the whole business rescue process was handled “atrociously” and there could have been so many alternatives and better options, which they suggested to the BRPs and would have helped the company and created more shareholder value.

However, Liasides said former Tongaat CEO Gavin Hudson was adamant he wanted to do a deal with the Rudland family.

Liasides said that eventually, thanks to the efforts of his colleague Dave Woollam, they frustrated that deal at the Takeover Regulation Panel (TRP) at literally the last minute on appeal.

But Liasides said it was not necessary for this to happen and so much time was wasted on the Rudland family deal, which could have been avoided because they were totally unsuitable buyers.

Liasides said at the early stages of Tongaat’s financial problems, the group was approached by an interested buyer about the sale of its Zimbabwe and Mozambique operations.

He said in those days the price being talked about was roughly R4 billion for each of those operations, which would have put Tongaat in a much better financial position at that stage, particularly as all the interest on its debt had accrued over the previous three or four years and the extremely cash-generative starch business was sold to Barloworld.

Barloworld in February 2020 announced the acquisition of the starch division, now renamed Ingrain South Africa, for R5.35 billion.

IDC condition ‘made no sense’

The Industrial Development Corporation (IDC) provided the post commencement finance (PCF) for Tongaat’s business rescue process but with the condition that the group must remain intact and none of its operations may be sold off.

Liasides said this condition did not make any business or financial sense.

He said that in terms of the Vision plan, the bankers in the lending group had to take a haircut.

Not all the details of this aspect of the proposed transaction have been released, but according to analysts, the bankers had about R7 billion of debt and took a haircut of about R3.6 billion.

Liasides stressed that if a deal had been done earlier for Tongaat, or if its Mozambique operations were sold, it would have resulted in a considerably better deal for all.

If the BRPs had then engaged and sold the Zimbabwean operations separately, it would have left Tongaat’s entire South African operation almost totally ungeared, he said.

“With all the land and sugar mills and operations, Tongaat would have been in a stronger position. From a development perspective, all the land north of Durban is predominantly held by Tongaat and there is underlying good value there.

“Now, at the end of the day shareholders are horribly diluted and the final outcome is poor for the lenders, trade creditors and shareholders.

“But it obviously satisfied the IDC,” he added.

“The approval of the Vision plan is disappointing for all the long-suffering shareholders, who ultimately paid the price for corrupt and incompetent leadership and poor oversight by the auditors.”

Tongaat has been in business rescue since 27 October 2022. Trading in its shares was suspended by the JSE on 19 July 2022 because of its failure to publish its financial results within the stipulated time period.

It is unclear when it will be able to publish its financial results and apply for the lifting of its JSE suspension.

#Tongaat #shareholders #advised #sell #share

TAGGED:advisedsellshareShareholdersTongaat
Share This Article
Facebook Twitter Pinterest Whatsapp Whatsapp LinkedIn Email Copy Link Print
Share
What do you think?
Love0
Sad0
Happy0
Sleepy0
Angry0
Dead0
Wink0
Previous Article Suits Creator Details One Change That Had A Huge Impact On The Show Suits Creator Details One Change That Had A Huge Impact On The Show
Next Article Make way for the bull market? Make way for the bull market?
- Advertisement -

Latest Post

BTC, ETH, XRP, BNB, SOL, DOGE, ADA, SUI, LINK, AVAX
BTC, ETH, XRP, BNB, SOL, DOGE, ADA, SUI, LINK, AVAX
Cryptocurrency
Guide to Pope Leo XIV’s inauguration
Guide to Pope Leo XIV’s inauguration
World News
Altcoins are on the verge of ‘most powerful rally’ since 2017 — Analyst
Altcoins are on the verge of ‘most powerful rally’ since 2017 — Analyst
Cryptocurrency
‘He’s the chosen one’: Meet the 14-year-old British boxer now fighting for Bahrain | World News
‘He’s the chosen one’: Meet the 14-year-old British boxer now fighting for Bahrain | World News
World News
Tokenization makes investing more accessible — Robinhood exec
Tokenization makes investing more accessible — Robinhood exec
Cryptocurrency
Trump’s Gulf Tour: The Money Deals, the Diplomacy and What Comes Next
Trump’s Gulf Tour: The Money Deals, the Diplomacy and What Comes Next
World News
- Advertisement -

You Might Also Like

Novo Nordisk weight-loss drug Wegovy launched in Germany, first big EU market By Reuters
Business

Novo Nordisk weight-loss drug Wegovy launched in Germany, first big EU market By Reuters

July 29, 2023
Bill Ackman cuts fundraising target for US fund IPO to bn
Business

Bill Ackman cuts fundraising target for US fund IPO to $2bn

July 30, 2024
Gran Tierra Energy Inc. Announces Fifth Consecutive Ecuador Oil Discovery from the Charapa-B6 Well
Business

Gran Tierra Energy Inc. Announces Fifth Consecutive Ecuador Oil Discovery from the Charapa-B6 Well

August 12, 2024
Summer Stock Gains, Annoying Surcharges: Sunday US Briefing
Business

Summer Stock Gains, Annoying Surcharges: Sunday US Briefing

July 30, 2023

About Us

NEWS JUNCTION (NewsJunction.xyz) Your trusted destination for global news. Stay informed with our timely and accurate reporting on diverse topics, including politics, technology, science, entertainment, sports, and more. Count on us for unbiased and reliable updates at your fingertips.

Quick Link

  • About
  • Disclaimer
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Contact

Top Categories

  • World News
  • Business
  • Technology
  • Entertainment
  • Cryptocurrency
  • Sports News
  • Trend
  • People

Subscribe

Subscribe to our newsletter to get our newest articles instantly!

    © 2023 News Junction.
    • Blog
    • Advertise
    • Contact
    Welcome Back!

    Sign in to your account

    Username or Email Address
    Password

    Lost your password?